Cyprus : Supreme Court has ruled in favour of Speed and Efficacy in the spirit of judicial cooperation

Cyprus : Supreme Court has ruled in favour of Speed and Efficacy in the spirit of judicial cooperation

 

In the case of Alpha Bank Cyprus Ltd v. Andrew Timothy Popple in March 2015 the Supreme Court of Cyprus had the opportunity to examine and apply Regulation (EC) No. 1393/2007, and made a significant statement in favour of simplification and acceleration of the process of service. The approach and analysis of the Highest Court of Cyprus can be seen to enhance the spirit of judicial cooperation and reflect the driving force behind the drafting of the provision.

 

Regulation (EC) No 1393/2007 of the Council of the European Union has provided the framework for service of judicial and extrajudicial documents in civil or commercial matters between EU Member States. The regulation provides the ground for the acceleration and simplification of the process of service between Member States by establishing transmitting and receiving agencies amongst the Member States.

 

 

In the above case, service had been effected in accordance to Regulation 1393/2007 at the address of Defendant No. 1 to a third party, who was described as the current tenant of the property.  The District Court of Paphos applied the relevant domestic law and held that service was invalid and improper since the documents were not served to the Defendant personally, a relative or an employer and thus did not give him the opportunity to become aware of the proceedings against him.

 

In turn, the Claimant applied for a Certiorari Order against the decision of the District Court of Paphos. The Supreme Court of Cyprus applied Regulation 1393/2007 and granted the Claimant with a Certiorari Order quashing the decision of the District Court.  The highest Court of Cyprus held that in the case before it, service had been effected in accordance with the law of the United Kingdom and therefore the decision of the District Court to hold the said service invalid was contrary to the provisions and spirit of the Regulation.  Moreover, it was highlighted that judicial procedures which require the transmittance of judicial and extrajudicial documents should be effected directly and rapidly between the Member States, having efficiency as their highest priority.

 

 Furthermore, the judgement underlined that according to Regulation (EC) No. 1393/2007 service must be effected in accordance to the law of the Member State where service is to be carried out, unless there is some other specific method of service requested on behalf of the applicant. 

 

Significance

 

Service is an essential feature of the outset of all litigation disputes. Regulation (EC) No. 1393/2007 has provided Claimants with the option of requesting service to be carried out in accordance with the law of the Member State where service is to be effected. Hence, Courts in Cyprus and in other Member States must not rely on domestic law in order to examine whether the service in question is valid and/or proper since the Regulation takes precedence over national law. Service is valid if a Court can ensure that a Claimant has obtained an official certificate confirming that service was carried out in accordance with the law of the Member State where it was effected.  The decision bears great significance as it gives direction to lower Courts to adopt and apply a spirit of judicial cooperation and subsequently promote efficient, simplified and speedy service. 

 

 

 

 

For further information on this topic please contact

Ms. Melissa Fikret (mfikret@pittaslegal.com) at SOTERIS PITTAS & CO LLC,

by telephone (+357 25 028460) or by fax (+357 25 028461)

 

 

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advise should be sought about your specific circumstances.

Публикации 2015

Cyprus: Guidance for Cyprus Courts on the duties o...
28 дек 2015 08:22

Cyprus: Guidance for Cyprus Courts on the duties owned by directors of a company to the sharehold [ ... ]

read more
Cyprus: Taxation – Amendments on the Double Tax Tr...
22 дек 2015 15:29

Cyprus: Taxation – Amendments on the Double Tax Treaty between the Republic of Cyprus and U [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: Guidance by the Supreme Court of Cyprus on...
14 дек 2015 12:53

CYPRUS: Guidance by the Supreme Court of Cyprus on “mens rea” for bounced cheques In October 2 [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: Double Tax Treaty between Cyprus and Swiss...
09 дек 2015 07:53

CYPRUS: Double Tax Treaty between Cyprus and Swiss Confederation On 15th October 2015, the Double T [ ... ]

read more
Cyprus: New Procedure for Issuing a Tax Residency ...
07 дек 2015 14:40

Cyprus: New Procedure for Issuing a Tax Residency Certificates   Tax Department, has recently iss [ ... ]

read more
КИПР: Отменён налог на прирост капитала на недвижи...
27 нояб 2015 06:47

КИПР: Отменён налог на прирост капитала на недвижимое  [ ... ]

read more
Tied Agents
23 нояб 2015 08:53

Tied Agents   A tied agent means a person established in a Member State, who, actin [ ... ]

read more
Cyprus: Possible guidance from the English Courts ...
20 нояб 2015 08:04

Cyprus: Possible guidance from the English Courts on the Interpretation of jurisdiction clauses a [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: WINDING OF COMPANIES – WINDING UP BY THE C...
18 нояб 2015 11:09

CYPRUS: WINDING OF COMPANIES – WINDING UP BY THE COURT (COMPULSORY WINDING UP)-INABILITY OF [ ... ]

read more
Cyprus: A possible amendment in the Law of Social ...
30 окт 2015 10:54

Cyprus: A possible amendment in the Law of Social Insurance Debtors   In Cyprus over [ ... ]

read more
Cyprus: Will the proposed amendment in relation to...
29 окт 2015 08:28

Cyprus: Will the proposed amendment in relation to the reduction of Judges in Family Courts solve [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: SERVICE OF COURT DOCUMENTS UNDER REGULATIO...
23 окт 2015 09:24

CYPRUS: SERVICE OF COURT DOCUMENTS UNDER REGULATION (EC) 1393/2007    In a case [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: APPOINTMENT OF RECEIVER IN AID OF EQUITABL...
21 окт 2015 13:59

CYPRUS: APPOINTMENT OF RECEIVER IN AID OF EQUITABLE EXECUTION OF CYPRUS JUDGMENT   I [ ... ]

read more
Cyprus : Supreme Court has ruled in favour of Spee...
20 окт 2015 10:19

Cyprus : Supreme Court has ruled in favour of Speed and Efficacy in the spirit of judicial cooper [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: Strengthening protection on money launderi...
19 окт 2015 13:43

CYPRUS: Strengthening protection on money laundering by the Introduction of the Fourth Anti-  [ ... ]

read more
The International Court of Arbitration of the Inte...
13 окт 2015 05:54

The International Court of Arbitration of the International Chamber of Commerce to communicate re [ ... ]

read more
A fight against corruption by the proposed introdu...
05 окт 2015 06:12

A fight against corruption by the proposed introduction of Criminal Record Certificates for Companie [ ... ]

read more
THE EXAMINERSHIP - Amendments to the Cyprus Legisl...
30 сен 2015 07:36

THE EXAMINERSHIP - Amendments to the Cyprus Legislation     The Compan [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS TAX. AMENDMENTS EXPECTED TO ARRIVE IN AUTUM...
23 сен 2015 06:24

CYPRUS TAX. AMENDMENTS EXPECTED TO ARRIVE IN AUTUMN 2015.   A. Income Tax Treatment  [ ... ]

read more
Changes to the Inheritance process under European ...
10 сен 2015 10:30

  Changes to the Inheritance process under European Succession Regulation 650/2012 & [ ... ]

read more
Renewal and Amendment of the Double Taxation Treat...
09 сен 2015 12:35

Renewal and Amendment of the Double Taxation Treaty between Cyprus and Ukraine   ___ [ ... ]

read more
ACTIVATION OF A CIF AUTHORISATION
01 сен 2015 09:25

ACTIVATION OF A CIF AUTHORISATION   According to Cyprus Securities and Exchange Comm [ ... ]

read more
RECENT DEVELOPMENTS IN CYPRUS DTT NETWORK
01 сен 2015 09:23

RECENT DEVELOPMENTS IN CYPRUS DTT NETWORK   Cyprus- Bahrain (DTT signed in March 201 [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS INVESTMENT FIRMS (CIFs)
01 сен 2015 09:16

CYPRUS INVESTMENT FIRMS (CIFs)   The Cyprus Investment Firms Law 144(I)/2007 provide [ ... ]

read more
The establishment of a New Administrative Court in...
19 авг 2015 05:55

The establishment of a New Administrative Court in Nicosia, Cyprus     &nbs [ ... ]

read more
The Approval of a Bill relating to the Sale of Loa...
06 авг 2015 06:43

The Approval of a Bill relating to the Sale of Loans   A bill under the name &ldquo [ ... ]

read more
Свежие изменения в налоговом режиме Кипра...
23 июль 2015 06:41

Свежие изменения в налоговом режиме Кипра
 9 июля 2015 к [ ... ]

read more
Парламент представил закон о решении вопроса о пра...
20 июль 2015 09:30

"Парламент представил закон о решении вопроса о праве  [ ... ]

read more
Закон о внесении изменений в Закон о Компаниях CAP...
16 июль 2015 06:31

Закон о внесении изменений в Закон о Компаниях CAP 113 N.4 [8 [ ... ]

read more
Схема натурализации инвесторов на Кипре...
30 март 2015 09:38

ПАСПОРТ ЕС   Схема натурализации инвесторов на Кипре   [ ... ]

read more
Особенности новой Исправленной Регуляции 1215/2012...
24 март 2015 07:02

Особенности новой Исправленной Регуляции 1215/2012
  Хорош [ ... ]

read more
Lis Alibi Pendens в соответствии с Регуляцией (ЕС...
02 фев 2015 10:50

Lis Alibi Pendens  в соответствии с Регуляцией (ЕС) № 44/2001 оюри [ ... ]

read more
More Publications 2015

Subscribe to our Publications

Image
We are dedicated to providing our clients with outstanding, highly personalized, legal representation.
Chrysanthou Mylona 10 
3030 - Limassol, Cyprus
© Soteris Pittas & Co LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Image